Site icon Santiva Chronicle

Sanibel Council to Revisit Riverview II Financing, $9.75M Grant

by SC Publisher Shannen Hayes

A rendering of Riverview II on the former site of Sanibel Fish House on Periwinkle Way proposed by Community Housing & Resources.

The Sanibel City Council will hold a special meeting Monday, Nov. 23, to examine the financial viability of Community Housing & Resources’ proposed Riverview II development and reconsider the city’s potential role in administering $9.75 million in federal disaster recovery funding.

The meeting follows months of discussions over the proposed 39-unit affordable housing development and a disagreement between Sanibel and Lee County over who should be responsible for administering the federal grant.

Council members previously expressed their opposition to having the city serve as the grant’s subrecipient, a role that would carry administrative, financial oversight and federal compliance responsibilities. Lee County has maintained that Sanibel should assume that responsibility rather than CHR.

The Lee County Board of County Commissioners postponed consideration of a proposed grant award on Nov. 3, with the matter expected to return for discussion Dec. 1.

Financial Questions Remain
Riverview II would provide 39 one-bedroom affordable rental apartments at 1523 Periwinkle Way, on property formerly occupied by the Sanibel Fish House restaurant. The project’s estimated cost is $19.25 million, including land acquisition and construction.

The special meeting will focus partly on differing assessments of CHR’s ability to finance the development and sustain its operations over the long term.

An August preliminary financial review prepared for Lee County by First Housing Development Corp. of Florida raised concerns about the project’s ability to support its proposed $7.496 million permanent mortgage through rental income.

The review estimated an average annual funding shortfall of approximately $505,642, totaling $5.06 million over the first 10 years of operations.

CHR disputes the suggestion that the project is financially unsustainable, arguing that the underwriting analysis does not adequately account for its nonprofit funding model, which relies on private donations, fundraising, grants and other revenue in addition to rental income.

In a memorandum submitted for Monday’s meeting, CHR President Erika Steiner said the organization’s 30-year financial projections show sufficient cash flow to meet its obligations while maintaining reserves.

CHR reported $11.2 million in net assets as of September 2025 and said it has never defaulted on a loan. The organization also pointed to its recent completion of Harkey House, a 15-unit affordable housing development, as evidence of its ability to manage major construction projects.

The city’s agenda memorandum acknowledges that CHR’s projections show positive cash flow but notes that they depend on continued fundraising and city financial support. The projections assume at least $1.1 million annually in donations and fundraising to support CHR’s overall housing portfolio.

The county’s underwriting findings remain preliminary and are subject to final review.

Disagreement Over Grant Responsibilities
The second major issue before the council is Lee County’s proposed nonbinding intent to award up to $9.75 million through the federal Community Development Block Grant-Disaster Recovery program established following Hurricane Ian.

Under the county’s proposed arrangement, Sanibel would serve as the grant subrecipient, entering into an agreement with Lee County and separate loan documents with CHR.

Although CHR would develop and operate Riverview II, the city would assume responsibilities for administering, monitoring and enforcing applicable federal grant requirements.

At its September meeting, the City Council reached a consensus against accepting that role. The city formally communicated its position to Lee County on Sept. 24, requesting that the county contract directly with CHR.

CHR is now asking council members to reconsider.

In its memorandum, CHR argues that Sanibel could help secure the federal funding without contributing additional municipal capital toward construction. The organization maintains that its financial resources, compliance procedures and outside consultants would minimize the city’s exposure to financial and administrative risks.

CHR also said it is pursuing alternative guarantors and that its proposed bank financing would not require a city guarantee.

However, the city’s potential responsibility for federal grant compliance remains a central issue, separate from whether Sanibel would guarantee the project’s bank loans.

City Manager Dana Souza noted in the agenda memorandum that city staff have not yet met with county officials to negotiate modifications to the proposed grant terms. Such discussions would require direction from the City Council.

Next Steps
Monday’s meeting will give council members an opportunity to question CHR representatives about the project’s financing, review the county’s proposed grant conditions and determine whether the city should reconsider its position or seek changes to the funding arrangement.

The meeting comes just eight days before Lee County commissioners are expected to revisit the proposed award on Dec. 1.

The Sanibel City Council special meeting begins at 9 a.m. Monday, Nov. 23, at MacKenzie Hall, 800 Dunlop Road. The meeting is open to the public.

Exit mobile version