Data provided courtesy of Eric Pfeifer, Broker-Owner, Pfeifer Realty Group, based on information from the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of REALTORS® for the period 01/21/26 – 01/27/26.
| Class | Address | Original List Price | Price | Subdivision Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Condo | 3111 Tennis Villas 3111 Captiva | $375,000.00 | $299,000.00 | Tennis Villas |
| Condo | 19 Beach Homes Captiva | $5,650,000.00 | $4,900,000.00 | Beach Homes |
| Condo | 200 Periwinkle Way 132 Sanibel | $649,000.00 | $499,000.00 | Lighthouse Point |
| Condo | 1610 Middle Gulf Dr D5 Sanibel | $559,000.00 | $499,000.00 | Spanish Cay |
| Condo | 5775 Baltusrol Court B302 Sanibel | $739,000.00 | $699,000.00 | Ibis At The Sanctuary |
| Condo | 610 Donax St 113 Sanibel | $930,000.00 | $875,000.00 | Sanibel Surfside |
| Condo | 1785 Middle Gulf Dr B303 Sanibel | $1,545,000.00 | $1,445,000.00 | Sanddollar |
| Condo | 2929 W Gulf Dr 207 Sanibel | $1,750,000.00 | $1,680,000.00 | Atrium |
| Residential | 1611 Sand Castle Rd Sanibel | $749,000.00 | $625,000.00 | Dunes Sanibel |
| Residential | 771 Rabbit Rd Sanibel | $849,000.00 | $699,000.00 | Sanibel Hamlet |
| Residential | 838/840 Rabbit Rd Sanibel | $979,000.00 | $699,000.00 | Windrow |
| Residential | 2011 Mitzi Ln Sanibel | $850,000.00 | $775,000.00 | Mitzi |
| Residential | 1730 Middle Gulf Dr Sanibel | $849,000.00 | $799,000.00 | Metes And Bounds |
| Residential | 9436 Yucca Ct Sanibel | $1,095,000.00 | $899,000.00 | Gumbo Limbo |
| Residential | 700 Nerita St Sanibel | $1,050,000.00 | $999,000.00 | Sanibel Shores |
| Residential | 3284 Twin Lakes Lane Sanibel | $1,195,000.00 | $1,095,000.00 | Little Lake Murex |
| Residential | 1490 Sand Castle Rd Sanibel | $1,350,000.00 | $1,250,000.00 | Dunes Sanibel |
| Residential | 5425 Shearwater Dr Sanibel | $1,390,000.00 | $1,295,000.00 | Herons Landing II |
| Residential | 241 Violet Dr Sanibel | $1,420,000.00 | $1,385,000.00 | Long Acre Lake |
| Residential | 6101 Starling Way 6101 Sanibel | $1,595,000.00 | $1,479,000.00 | Dinkins Bayou |
| Residential | 2179 Starfish Ln Sanibel | $1,650,000.00 | $1,599,000.00 | Butterknife |
| Residential | 1159 Junonia St Sanibel | $1,795,000.00 | $1,695,000.00 | Sanibel Shores |