Data provided courtesy of Eric Pfeifer, Broker-Owner, Pfeifer Realty Group, based on information from the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of REALTORS® for the period 02/25/26 – 03/02/26.
| Class | Address | Original List Price | Price | Subdivision Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Condo | 15067 Captiva Dr 2 Captiva | $3,800,000.00 | $3,575,000.00 | Captiva Bay Villas |
| Residential | 15301 Captiva Drive Captiva | $4,398,000.00 | $3,995,000.00 | Gores A M |
| Residential | 16979 Captiva Drive Captiva | $9,250,000.00 | $5,700,000.00 | Metes And Bounds |
| Commercial | 1640 Periwinkle Way 4 Sanibel | $399,000.00 | $224,000.00 | |
| Condo | 641 Periwinkle Way A3 Sanibel | $275,000.00 | $299,000.00 | Captains Walk |
| Condo | 601 Periwinkle Way D1 Sanibel | $350,000.00 | $329,000.00 | Captains Walk |
| Condo | 1610 Middle Gulf Dr B3 Sanibel | $510,000.00 | $425,000.00 | Spanish Cay |
| Condo | 5117 Sea Bell Rd B101 Sanibel | $649,000.00 | $599,000.00 | Blind Pass |
| Condo | 200 Periwinkle Way 124 Sanibel | $675,000.00 | $649,000.00 | Lighthouse Point |
| Condo | 200 Periwinkle 214 Sanibel | $720,000.00 | $689,000.00 | Lighthouse Point |
| Condo | 827 E Gulf Dr G7 Sanibel | $729,000.00 | $699,000.00 | Sanibel Arms West |
| Condo | 845 E Gulf Dr 121 Sanibel | $849,000.00 | $799,000.00 | Sanibel Moorings |
| Condo | 2230 Camino Del Mar Dr 4A2 Sanibel | $975,000.00 | $899,000.00 | Oceans Reach |
| Condo | 2230 Camino Del Mar Dr 1C4 Sanibel | $999,000.00 | $975,000.00 | Oceans Reach |
| Condo | 2311 W Gulf Dr 13 Sanibel | $1,099,000.00 | $1,069,000.00 | White Sands |
| Condo | 527 E Gulf Dr 203 Sanibel | $749,000.00 | $1,095,000.00 | Gulf Beach |
| Condo | 527 E Gulf Dr 204 Sanibel | $749,000.00 | $1,095,000.00 | Gulf Beach |
| Condo | 2777 W Gulf Dr 309 Sanibel | $1,150,000.00 | $1,100,000.00 | Nutmeg Village |
| Condo | 2915 W Gulf Dr A-201 Sanibel | $1,395,000.00 | $1,195,000.00 | Villas of Sanibel |
| Condo | 2445 W Gulf Dr E6 Sanibel | $1,595,000.00 | $1,250,000.00 | Pointe Santo De Sanibel |
| Residential | 1812 Ibis Ln Sanibel | $435,000.00 | $395,000.00 | Sanibel Lake Estates |
| Residential | 1657 Atlanta Plaza Dr Sanibel | $674,000.00 | $664,000.00 | Sanibel Highlands |
| Residential | 996 Greenwood Ct N Sanibel | $950,000.00 | $739,000.00 | Dunes Sanibel |
| Residential | 1448 Albatross Rd Sanibel | $879,000.00 | $799,000.00 | Dunes Sanibel |
| Residential | 720 Durion Ct Sanibel | $1,190,000.00 | $975,000.00 | Rocks East |
| Residential | 1550 Wilton Ln Sanibel | $1,350,000.00 | $1,250,000.00 | Gumbo Limbo |
| Residential | 952 Kings Crown Dr Sanibel | $1,395,000.00 | $1,295,000.00 | Shell Harbor |
| Residential | 1310 Par View Dr Sanibel | $1,395,000.00 | $1,299,000.00 | Beachview CC Estates |
| Residential | 3351 Barra Circle Sanibel | $1,550,000.00 | $1,374,000.00 | Brightwater |
| Residential | 742 Nerita St Sanibel | $1,800,000.00 | $1,550,000.00 | Sanibel Shores |
| Residential | 979 Whelk Dr Sanibel | $1,695,000.00 | $1,550,000.00 | Shell Harbor |
| Residential | 4452 Waters Edge Lane Sanibel | $1,848,000.00 | $1,794,000.00 | Gulf Shores |
| Residential | 985 Oyster Ct Sanibel | $2,295,000.00 | $1,998,000.00 | Shell Harbor |
| Residential | 6407 Pine Ave Sanibel | $1,879,000.00 | $1,999,000.00 | Del Sega |
| Residential | 1044 Fish Crow Rd Sanibel | $2,250,000.00 | $2,175,000.00 | Gulf Shores |
| Residential | 970 Victoria Way Sanibel | $2,290,000.00 | $2,250,000.00 | Victoria Cove |
| Residential | 1730 Jewel Box Dr Sanibel | $2,849,000.00 | $2,499,000.00 | Sanibel Isles |
| Residential | 1157 Bird Ln Sanibel | $3,495,000.00 | $2,999,000.00 | Richardsons O L |
| Residential | 411 Bella Vista Way E Sanibel | $3,595,000.00 | $3,200,000.00 | Colony Beach Estates |
| Residential | 1581 San Carlos Bay Dr Sanibel | $3,995,000.00 | $3,299,000.00 | Sanibel Isles |
| Residential | 431 Bella Vista Way E Sanibel | $3,950,000.00 | $3,590,000.00 | Colony Beach Estates |
| Vacant Land | 1321 Seaspray Ln Sanibel | $859,000.00 | $799,000.00 | Seaspray |