A Partisan Attack on Voting by Mail

The Santiva Chronicle publishes opinions and letters on topics that are important to Sanibel and Captiva. They may be submitted via e-mail at news@santivachronicle.com. Views expressed are not necessarily those of the Santiva Chronicle.

As a senior citizen I benefited greatly from the ease and convenience of casting my vote in the 2020 general election by mail. I was not alone: some 4.8 million of my fellow Floridians did the same. The process worked smoothly according to local election officials. There is no evidence of widespread abuse or fraud. Now Republican lawmakers in Tallahassee are attempting to subvert the system by retroactively reducing the period for which a filed request to vote by mail can be honored.

Under current Florida law, a filed request to vote by mail is good for two general election cycles. Senate Bill 90, now before the Senate Oversight and Governmental Accountability Committee, would reduce that period to one. And it is more insidious that that. Voters who filed a request to vote by mail in the fall of 2020 would have been eligible to vote by mail without further action on their part in the 2022 primary and general election. Senate Bill 90 explicitly expunges that promise by terminating the request at the end of calendar year 2020 so that a voter must file a new request to vote by mail for the 2022 elections.

What purpose does this change accomplish? Sponsors claim it will prevent ballots from being left at old addresses. But when the named recipient no longer resides at the mailing address, the Post office returns the ballot o the election office marked as “undeliverable. The actual effect is that it creates an unnecessary hurdle to voting by mail. The legislature’s own fiscal analysis concludes that if it results in many voters applying again to vote by mail for 2022 it will increase costs to the counties and administrative burdens for local election officials. So why the push to change the law?

The answer is as plain as day: Right now Democrats hold a lead of more than 800,000 over Republicans in mail ballot requests.. The passage of this measure will erase the Democrats’ advantage as Governor DeSantis runs for reelection.

The calculation here is brazen. If more Democrats vote by mail than Republicans, make voting by mail more difficult. For some Republican lawmakers that partisan payoff outweighs the cost to counties and the extra burden on those, both Democrats and Republicans, who wish to vote by mail. And sadly, many will fail to resubmit another request next year and end up not voting at all instead of standing in lines at the polls. Voting from home is a real boon to senior citizens, the disabled, those caring for the aged and ill, people working long hours, hard- pressed single parents and those with limited transportation– of both parties. It is time to let our representatives know we don’t like being treated as pawns in a game of blatant political partisanship..

C. Ronald Ellington

C. Ronald Ellington is a retired member of the faculty of the University of Georgia School of Law where he taught for over 40 years, serving as Dean for part of that time. He earned his undergraduate degree from Emory University and his law degree from the University of Virginia and a graduate degree in law from Harvard University . At Georgia, he held the Cleveland Chair in Legal Ethics and Professionalism and was named a Josiah Meigs Professor,, the University’s highest honor for teaching excellence. .He now resides on Sanibel.

Comments (4)

  1. Sandra Greco MD

    I completely agree & compliment C. Ronald Ellington on his accurate, & informative report. It’s more important than ever that we contact our congressmen, senators, & governor DeSantis & voice our strong opposition to SB 90, & other similar bills that would weaken our voting rights, & have also been proposed.

  2. Dr. Ellington is absolutely right. Mail-in voting enjoys a stellar record with no significant drawbacks; its opponents dream up arguments simply to avoid a voting outcome they don’t want, This is not how democracy should work, so give it a rest!!

  3. I want to commend Ronald Ellington for pointing out the insidious efforts by our Republican state legislators to needlessly complicate Florida’s vote-by-mail procedures to make them less convenient to use.
    70% of Sanibel voters voted by mail in the recent election. Need I say more.
    Apparently a significant majority of mail in voters are Democrats and honestly I’m not sure why. But this should not be relevant.
    This is a blatant partisan effort to limit voting by mail and should be called out for what it is at all levels of Florida government.
    Thank you Mr. Ellington.
    Gary Dutton, Sanibel

  4. A P.S. to my comment of yesterday. When I said we should call out the effort to complicate and limit mail in voting for what it is, I should have added what it is – plain and simple it’s voter suppression aimed at all voters but adversely affecting all Florida voters especially those of us voters who depend on mail voting for health and safety reasons or who are away from Florida on Election Day or for plain old convenience. I doubt that most of you out there reading this ever thought that you’d be targets of voter suppression efforts. But you are.
    Gary Dutton

Leave a Reply to Gary DuttonCancel reply

We are interested in articulate, well-informed remarks that are relevant to the article. We welcome your advice, your criticism and your unique insights into the issues of the day. To be approved for publication, your comments should be civil and avoid name-calling. It may take up to 24 hours for your comment to appear, if it is approved.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.